Close Search Menu

Let Us Help

Music as Prayer: Sir James Macmillan and the Welcoming Children in Worship Project

the choir and director prepare for the recording session
Professor Peter Kadeli prepares the University Chamber Choir for their recording session of several Macmillan compositions.

On a chilly April morning last semester, Sir James Macmillan, the world-renowned Scottish classical composer and conductor, sat inside St. Vincent Chapel, off to the side, relaxed and quietly taking in the scene. Technicians moved quickly across the floor of the chapel, checking cameras, connections, sound, and lighting. Purple Lenten banners cascaded down the walls of the chapel, and rich wood tones and brass organ pipes formed a backdrop for the University’s Chamber Choir, who stood assembled in front of the altar, dressed in performance attire, and focused on their conductor, Peter Kadeli. Very soon they would begin recording three of Macmillan’s compositions—in his presence. 

With the preparations complete and the cameras recording, the first sounds swelled forth from the students, as they began to sing Macmillan’s “Be Who God Meant You to Be.” During a break in the recording, sophomore Carolyn Shaffer reflected on the piece’s oft-repeated refrain, “Be who God meant you to be.” 

“Repetition in music signifies that something is important, and finding that repetition helps bring out the meaning,” she explained. “It brings you into a very spiritual head space and it’s very comforting; it’s very calming.”

That comforting and calming “spiritual head space” is more commonly known as prayer or worship, and that is the heart of the project Macmillan came to campus to support.

Welcoming Children in Worship: Learning to pray and worship

Macmillan was on campus as part of the Welcoming Children in Worship program, a Catholic University program funded by the Lilly Endowment Inc.'s Nurturing Children Through Worship and Prayer Initiative.

The primary purpose of his visit was to assist the program by recording a series of conversations on the topic of introducing children to sacred music. While here, he also participated in a public discussion with Peter Kadeli and a live recording session with the University Chamber Choir of three of his compositions, which will be used as an online resource for the program.

Led by Jem Sullivan, Ph.D., associate professor in the School of Theology and Religious Studies, the Welcoming Children in Worship program aims to develop an array of pastoral resources to help nurture and form children in worship and prayer in the Catholic tradition.

With the aid of the Lilly Endowment Inc. grant, the project collaborators are building a website that contains a range of resources for parents, pastors, catechists, liturgists, and teachers. These include formation resources on the meaning of liturgical signs, words, and gestures of worship; sacred music for worship and prayer; sacred art; and a “Shepherds Reflect” resource that contains reflections from Catholic bishops, priests, and scholars on the liturgical formation of families and children.  

“We have about 1,600 subscribers from around the world currently on the website,” explained Sullivan, “and we put out regular communications to our subscribers. Every month we have new resources that we send out to this virtual community we’re building.”

In addition to faculty from the University’s School of Theology and Religious Studies, program collaborators include faculty from the University’s education and music programs and the International Center for Ward Method Studies, as well as Catholic University alumnus Father Phillip Ganir, S.J., of Boston College’s School of Theology and Ministry, who is a music consultant on the project.

Macmillan with Jem Sullivan and others participating in the recording
Left to right: At the start of the recording session, project collaborators Professor Jem Sullivan, Sir James Macmillan, Professor Peter Kadeli, and Father Phillip Ganir, S.J., assembled for a photo.

Sullivan and her team also work with the Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate (CARA) and with pilot groups of Catholic educators and religious instructors in the Dioceses of Columbus and Bridgeport. CARA surveyed 189 dioceses to find out what types of resources practitioners in the field need to help them in the formation of children, and the pilot groups of Catholic educators and religious instructors in the dioceses gave feedback on the project resources and how they are using them.

“One thing that came out of that was the need to help liturgical musicians have a good sense of theology and the Church’s understanding of the importance of this music,” Sullivan recalled. 

But how, the team wondered, would they accomplish this?  As they were brainstorming, Father Phillip suggested creating something along the lines of Leonard Bernstein’s Young People’s Concerts, in which a composer speaks about the importance of music and of particular pieces of music. 

“I knew James Macmillan and thought he’d be perfect,” said Sullivan. “He’s on an international stage, world-renowned, but so much of what he does is infused by his Catholic faith, and he has a keen attention to children.”

Macmillan accepted the invitation, and during his visit to campus the team recorded more than two days of conversations between him and Father Phillip, centered on this question: How do we introduce children to the rich repertoire of sacred music? Ultimately, the conversations will be released via a series of several videos that will be hosted as resources on the project website. The video recordings of the choir performing his compositions will be a complementary resource, providing music and performance inspiration for children’s choir directors and others.

Song as prayer: An evening conversation with Sir James Macmillan

“He who sings prays twice,” said St. Augustine.

Macmillan would likely agree. In fact, by devoting much of his talent and energy to composing sacred music for the liturgy, he helps the faithful do just that: offer their hymns as prayer.

As Macmillan told the audience gathered that April evening for his public appearance, “There's a profound umbilical link between music and the sacred ... music is part of the liturgy. It’s not an add-on for aesthetic values. It’s an absolute essential core part of what it means to be a praying church.”

During the discussion, he reflected on the role of a composer of liturgical music, noting the profound responsibility he or she bears.

“When a composer writes music for the choir,” he said, “it’s not written as an act of egotism or narcissism. It’s a great responsibility for the composer when he or she writes the liturgy … you are writing to carry the thoughts and prayers and meditations of the people of God to the altar of God.”

Macmillan also spoke to the crucial importance of beauty, both in the Catholic Mass and in the secular world, noting that we overlook it to our own detriment.  Advocating for a greater recollection of beauty in Catholic preaching and teaching, he probed the topic with a few questions about sacred music for his audience.

“The church should be asking questions: Why is it that that music is speaking to secular people in the concert world? Why is the music of Palestrina packing out concerts? … Why have we abandoned it when the secular world is exulting in it and embracing it?” he wondered.

Sir James MacMillan gives a lecture at CUA

Sacred music: At home at Catholic University

One place that certainly isn’t abandoning sacred music and beauty is Catholic University. The University recently relaunched its sacred music program and hired assistant professor and director of choral activities Dr. Peter Kadeli to head it.

For Kadeli, beauty is central to the mission of the sacred music program.  Quoting Pope Benedict XVI in his discussion with MacMillan, he emphasized that “the arts can open the door to the infinite, to a beauty and a truth that goes beyond the ordinary.”

The University’s Sacred Music program aims to achieve this by thoroughly immersing its students in liturgical, theoretical, and historical studies and providing superlative standards of musical performance that, together, prepare the students to thrive in their careers as musicians and conduits of beauty.

Asked about the uniqueness of the program, Kadeli responds that the program really speaks to the liturgy and the faith as the object and source of the music, and it responds to “what it means to develop one’s talents and musical skills not only for one’s pursuits but for nurturing the gifts that God has given us.”

“Catholic University is such a unique place to come and study anything right now, but especially sacred music,” Kadeli said. “You can go to a lot of places to study a lot of other things, but not sacred music, not liturgical music grounded in Catholic identity.” 

Learn more about Welcoming Children in Worship.

Topics

Related News